The top baseball players of the early 1900s called Roger Bresnahan the greatest catcher and all-around player of the time.

Christy Mathewson

Miller Huggins

John McGraw

Joe McGinnity

Ty Cobb

Jack Chesbro

Christy Mathewson

Joe Tinkers, Johnny Evers, Frank Chance

Ty Cobb

Johnny Evers

Tris Speaker